The Influence of External Auditing in Limiting the Creative Accounting Practices in SMEs

(Mohammed Ibrahim Bu haya and Abdullah Abdulmohsen Alsdi)

---

Abstract

This study aims to identify the role of external auditing in limiting the practice of creative accounting among Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Creative accounting involves providing fraudulent numbers and may be contained through efficient external auditing and the use of the rules and conduct of professional ethics. To achieve study objectives, a descriptive approach was taken by conducting a field study using a comprehensive inventory method. To suit the nature of the study, this method targeted all audit offices not licensed to practice with joint-stock companies. A questionnaire was used to collect data from the study population, and SPSS was used to analyze the results. The study results indicate that efficiency in external auditing contributes to limiting the practice of creative accounting among SMEs through procedures and audit plans, optimal use of resources (e.g., auditors), and knowledge and use of the rules and conduct of professional ethics. This study also composed a set of proposals to serve practitioners and decision makers, including measures that ensure and develop procedures in audit offices that contribute to discovering and reducing illegal practices.
KEYWORDS
accounting offices, auditing efficiency, financial statements, fraudulent accounting, professional conduct, professional ethics

PDF

References

Abdel Basset, L. and Nihad, S. (2021). Dawr Altadqiq Alkharijii Fi Alhadi Min Mumarasat Almuhasabat Aliibdaeia: Dirasat Maydaniatan Laeayinatan Min Almihniiyn 'The Role of External Audit in Limiting the Practice of Creative Accounting: A field Study of a Sample of Professionals'. Master's Dissertation, Mohamed Boudiaf University, M’Sila, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Abo Alam, R.M. (2007). Manahij Albahth Fi Aleulum Alnafsiat Walsulukia 'Research Methods in Psychological and Behavioral Sciences'. Cairo, Egypt: Universities Publishing House. ]in Arabic[
Ahmed, A.A. and Ahmed, I.J. (2019). Iidarat Alarbah 'Earnings Management'. Algeria: Dar Al-Ilm wal-Iman.  ]in Arabic[
Al Baldawi, A.A. (2009). Asalib Aliihsa Lileulum Aliaiqtisadiat Aa Iidarat Alaemal Mae Astikhdam Barnamaj SPSS 'Statistics Methods for Economics and Business Administration Using SPSS'. Amman, Jordan: Dar Wael Publishing. ]in Arabic[
Al Olimat, N.H. and Al Shbail, M.O. (2021). The mediating effect of external audit quality on the relationship between corporate governance and creative accounting. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(1), 149–57. 
Al Qahtani, S.S., Alaamri, A.S., Al Mthhb, M.M. and Alomar, B.A. (2010). Manhaj Albahth Fi Aleulum Alsulukia 'Research Methodology in Behavioral Sciences'. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Modern National Printing Presses. ]in Arabic[ 
Al Zahraa, M.F. (2020). Athar Alailtizamat Almihniat Lilmarajie Alkharijii Ealaa Muajahat Asalib Almuhasabat Aliibdaeia 'The Impact of the External Auditor’s Professional Obligations on Confronting Creative Accounting Methods'. PhD Thesis, University of Martyr Hamma Lakhdar, El Oued, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Al Zomar, I.S., Ashmawy, K.S., Brakat, A.A., Abdulhamed, M.M., Helmi, E.A. and Sabrah, M.S. (2018). Muqadimat Fi Mabadi Wabaramij Almurajaea 'Introduction to Auditing Principles and Programs'. Cairo, Egypt: Faculty of Commerce Press, Cairo University. ]in Arabic[
Alian, R.M., Gonim, O.M., Abo Sonsos, J.A. and Abo zid, M.S. (2008). Asalib Albahth Aleilmii Watatbiqatuh Fi Altakhtit Waliidara 'Scientific Research Methods and their Applications in Planning and Management'. Jordan: Dar Safaa. ]in Arabic[
Baloul, R., Alaayb, Z., Bkakrah, S. and Orosi, H. (2022). Dawr Almurajaeat Alkharijiat Fi Jawdat Altaqarir Almalia 'The Role of External Audit in the Quality of Financial Reports'. Master's Dissertation, University of Martyr Hamma Lakhdar, El Oued, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Capital Market Authority. (2018). Qawaeid Tasjil Murajiei Hisabat Almanshat Alkhadieat Li'iishraf Alhayyati 'Rules for Registering Auditors of Establishments Subject to the Authority’s Supervision'. Available at: https://cma.org.sa/MediaCenter/PR/Pages/Rules-Registering-Auditors-of-Entities.aspx (accessed on 20/10/2022) ]in Arabic[
Drábková, Z. and Pech, M. (2022). Comparison of creative accounting risks in small enterprises: The different branches perspective. Business Administration and Management, 25(1), 113–29.
Faraj, H.K. (2023). Athar nawe muraqib alhisabat ealaa kafaat almurajaeat alkharijiati 'The effect of the type of auditor on the efficiency of external auditing'. Journal of Accounting Research, 10(3), 547–96. ]in Arabic[
General Authority for Statistics. (2023). Masah Almunshat Alsaghirat Walmutawasita 'Small and Medium Enterprises Survey'. Available at: https://www.stats.gov.sa/ar/919 (accessed on 15/07/2023) [in Arabic]
Ghamri, W.H.M. (2020). The relationship between creative accounting risks and auditing risks from the perspective of external auditors in Saudi Arabia. Financial Risk and Management Reviews. 6(1), 22–39.
Haddadi, S. (2020). Dawr Muhafiz Alhisabat Fi Aiktishaf Mumarasat Almuhasabat Aliibdaeiat Walhadi Min Athariha Ealaa Jawdat Almaelumat Almalia 'The Role of the Auditor in Discovering Creative Accounting Practices and Reducing their Effects on the Quality of Financial Information'. PhD Thesis, Mohamed Boudiaf University, M’Sila, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Ismail, M.A. and Ahmed, I.J. (2019). Almuhasabat Walsiyasat Alnaqdia 'Accounting and Monetary Policies'. Algeria: Dar Al-Ilm wal-Iman. ]in Arabic[
Jalabi, S. (2018). Dawr Almurajaeat Alkharijiat Fi Alhadi Min Mumarasat Wa Asalib Almuhasabat Aliibdaeia 'The Role of External Audit in Limiting the Practice and Methods of Creative Accounting'. Master's Dissertation, Mohamed Boudiaf University, M’Sila, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Mazia, G., Dlal, G., Nathirah, H. and Amal, A. (2020). Dawr Almarajie Alkharijii Fi Muharabat Asalib Talaeub Almuhasabat Al'iibdaeia 'The Role of the External Auditor in Combating Creative Accounting Manipulation Methods'. Master's Dissertation, University of Martyr Hamma Lakhdar, El Oued, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Melhem, S.M. (2005). Manahij Albahth Fi Altarbiat Waeilm Alnafs 'Find in Education and Science Curricula Psychology'. Amman, Jordan: Dar Al Masirah. ]in Arabic[
Mostafa, A. (2017). Iishkaliat aistidamat almuasasat alsaghirat walmutawasitat fi aljazayir 'On the problem of sustainability of small and medium enterprises in Algeria'. In: National Forum on the Problem of Sustainability of Small and Medium Enterprises in Algeria, Martyr Hamma Lakhdar University, El Oued, Algeria, 06–07/12/2017. ]in Arabic[
Qadari, A., Rdwani, A. and Taleb, A. (2020). Asalib Almuhasabat Aliibdaeiat Wa Atharuha Ealaa Misdaqiat Alqawayim Almalia 'Creative Accounting Methods and their Impact on the Credibility of Financial Statements'. Master's Dissertation, University of Martyr Hamma Lakhdar, El Oue, Algeria. ]in Arabic[
Saudi Organization for Chartered and Professional Accountant. (2022). Qawaeid Suluk Wadab Almihna 'Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics'. Available at: https://www.socpa.org.sa/3477 (accessed on 20/07/2022) ]in Arabic[
Shabon, A., Al Shwerif, A. and Dihom, A. (2021). Madaa kafa'at almurajaeat alkharijiat fi alhadi min mumarasat almuhasabat al'iibdaeia “dirasat tatbiqiat eali makatib almurajaeat bimadinat misratihi” 'The extent of the effectiveness of external audit in limiting the practice of creative accounting “An applied study on audit offices in the city of Misrata”'. Sebha University Journal of Research and Applied Sciences, 20(1), 87–95. ]in Arabic[