Spiritual Experience Among Religions

(Samia Yassin Al-Badri)

---

Abstract

This article endeavors to comprehensively explore the spiritual experiences within Christianity, and Islam. It aims to examine the similarities and dissimilarities between Monasticism (existing in Christianity) and Sufism (existing in Islam). The article delves into inquiries regarding whether monasticism serves as the origin of Sufism, the potential reciprocal influence between the two phenomena, and the absence of any connection between them. To accomplish this, the paper employs both inductive and analytical methodologies. Pertaining to similarities, both Monasticism and Sufism encompass disengagement from worldly affairs, seclusion from society, renunciation of materialistic existence, utilization of chants and hymns. Nonetheless, these entities diverge in terms of their approaches towards places of worship, inclination towards celibacy, reliance on symbolic language, religious rituals, the significance of silence, attitudes towards women, as well as the expressions of love and fear. Ultimately, a prevalent discovery emerges that spiritual experiences transcend religious boundaries. Despite variations in individuals' religious backgrounds, the spiritual dimension constitutes a shared element among them. 
KEYWORDS
Gratitude method, intuitive method, knowledge philosophy, knowledge source, religious philosophy, spiritual exercise
PDF

References

Abbas, R. (n/a). Pascal Wa Falsafah Al-Insaan ‘Pascal and Human Philosophy’. Cairo: Al-Ma’rifah University House. [in Arabic]
Al-Attar, F. (2018). Tadhkirah Al-Awliyaa ‘Remembrance of the Saints’. Sharjah: Dar Al-Farqad for Printing and Publishing. [in Arabic]
Al-Ghamdi, S. (2022). Al-mustashriqun wa al-tasawwuf dirasah taliliyyah ‘Orientalists and sufism: An analytical study’. Journal of International Islamic Sciences, Al-Madinah International University, 6(1), 169–207. [in Arabic] 
Al-Ghazali, M. (1980). Almunqidh Min Aldalal ‘Savior from Delusion’. Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm. [in Arabic]
Al-Ghazali, M. (2005). Ihyaa ‘Uloum Al-Deen ‘Revival of religious sciences’. Beirut: Dar Ibn Hazm. [in Arabic]
Al-Husayni, K. and Zwain, L. (2013). Al-Rahbana mafhumuha wa dawruha fi al-mujtama ‘Monasticism, its concept and role in society’. Kufa Journal, Baghdad University. 6(15), 143–72. [in Arabic]
Al-Kashani, H. (2012). Asmaa Allaah Al-Husana Ma’aneeha wa Khawasaha ‘The Beautiful Names of Allah, Their Meanings and Peculiarities’. Lebanon: Al-Balagh Foundation. [in Arabic]
Al-Qushairy, A. (2012). Alrisalah Alqushiriah ‘Al-Qushairy’s Message’. Cairo: Dar al-Maarif. [in Arabic]
Al-Saholi, S. (2006). Bayna mafahim al-tasawwuf al-islami w al-mafahim al-masihiyyah: Dirasah muqaranah ‘Between the concepts of islamic sufism and christian concepts, A comparative study’. Al-Asmariya Islamic University Journal. 6(n/a), 427–62. [in Arabic]
Al-Sheikh, M. (2017). Masalat al-tajribah al-deeniyyah ‘ind al-falaasifah al-muhadditheen ‘The issue of religious experience among modern philosophers’. Al-Tafaahum Journal, Ministry of Endowments and Religious Affairs, Sultanate of Oman, 15(55), 167–204. [in Arabic]
Al-Sulami, M. (1996). Tabaqaat Al-Suufiyyah ‘The Ranks of the Sufis’. Beirut: Daar Al-Kutub Al-‘Ilmiyyah. [in Arabic]
Al-Tusi, A. (1960). Al-Luma’ ‘The Illunination’. Cairo: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Haditha. [in Arabic]
Andre, T. (2003). Al-Tasawwuf Al-Islami ‘Islamic Sufism’. Cologne: Al-Jamal Publications. [in Arabic]
Applezi, H. (2014). Al-Janib Al-Mudhlim Fi Al-Tarikh Al-Masḥi ‘The Dark Side of the Christian History’. Beirut: Dar Qutaiba for Printing and Publishing. [in Arabic]
Blaise, P. (1972). Khawaatir ‘Ideas’. Beirut: The Lebanese Committee for the Translation of Masterpieces. [in Arabic]
Bobrik, R. (2010). Barakat Al-Nisaa Al-Deen Biseega Al-Muannath ‘The Blessing of Religious Women in the Feminine Form’. Casablanca: Afiriqiya Al-Sharq Press. [in Arabic]
Chadwick, H. (2016). Augustinous ‘Augustine’. United Kingdom: Hindawi Foundation for Education. [in Arabic]
Christ, C. (2006). Al-Sufiyyah Al-Nisawiyyah Al-Gaws ‘Amiqan Wa Al-Su’ud Ila Al-Satḥ ‘Feminist Sufism Diving Deep and Rising to the Surface’. Cairo: Dar Afaq for publication and distribution. [in Arabic]
Cyrils, A. (2011). ‘An Al-Marha Wa Gita Al-Rahs Dirasah Wa Sharḥ. ‘About Women and Head Coverings, Study and Explanation’. 3rd edition. Beirut: Judhuur for Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]
Eckenstein, L. (1896). Al-Marha Fi Dhill Al-Rahbanah Fusoul ‘an Hayat San Lur wa Al-Dir bayna 500 Wa 1500 Ba’da Al-Milad ‘Women in the Shadow of Monasticism Chapters on the life of Saint-Laur and the Monastery between 500 and 1500 AD’. Britain: Cambridge University Press. [in Arabic]
Fayez, M. (2020). Limadha La Yujad Tasawwuf Fi Al-Masiḥiyyah ‘Why Is There No Sufism in Christianity?’ Cairo: Dar Risaalatona. [in Arabic]
Habermas, J. (1995). Al-Falsafah Al-Almaniyyah: Al-Tasawwuf Al-Yahudi ‘German Philosophy, Jewish Mysticism’. Casablanca: Arab Cultural Center. [in Arabic]
Hassan, M. (1997) Athar Al-Fikr Al-Istishraqi Fi Al-Mujtama’at Al-Islamiyyah ‘Effects of Orientalist Thought in Islamic Societies’. Cairo: ‘Ayn for Researches and Humanities and Social Studies. [in Arabic]
Ibn-Arabi, M. (1985). Al-Futouhaat Al-Makiyyah ‘The Meccan Inspirations’. 2nd edition. Cairo: The Egyptian General Book Organization. [in Arabic]
Ibn-Rushd, M. (1999). Al-Kashf ‘An Manaahij Al-Adillah Fi ‘Aqaaid Al-Millah ‘The Disclosure of the Methodologies of Proofs on the Doctrines of Religion’. Beirut: Studies Center for Arab Unity. [in Arabic]
Ibn-Taymiyyah, A. (1986). Minhaaj Al-Sunnah ‘The Methodology of the Sunnah’. Riyadh: Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University. [in Arabic]
Ibn-Taymiyyah, A. (1999). Dar’ Ta’aarud Al-‘Aql Wa An-Naql ‘Nullifying Conflict Between the Reason and the Revelation’. 2nd edition. Riyadh: Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University. [in Arabic]
Ibn-Taymiyyah, A. (2003). Bayaan Talbees Al-Jahmiyyah Fi Tasees Bida’ihim Al-Kalamiyyah ‘An Explanation of the Confusions of the Jahmiyyah in Establishing the Heresies of the Science of Theology’. Madinah: King Fahd Complex for the Printing of the Glorious Qur’an. [in Arabic]
Issa, A. (2007). Haqaiq ‘An Al-Tasawwuf ‘Facts about Sufism’. Aleppo: Dar Al-Irfan. [in Arabic]
James, W. (2020). Tanawwu’at Al-Tajribah Al-Deeniyyah ‘Variations of Religious Experience’. Beirut: Nuhoud Center. [in Arabic]
Kocharoen, S. (n/a). Tabi’ah Al-Tajribah Al-Deeniyyah Fi Falsafah William James ‘The Nature of Religious Experience in the Philosophy of William James’. Beirut: Nama Center. [in Arabic]
Marteurs, T. (2016). Tarikh Al-Qalansuwah Al-Rahbaniyyah ‘The History of the Monastic Hood’ Cairo: Coptic Treasures Project. [in Arabic]
Marzouk, I. (2006), Mafahim al-tasawwuf bayna al-masiḥiyyah wa al-islam ‘Concepts of sufism between Christianity and Islam’. Sebha University Journal of Human Sciences, 5(1), 5–23. [in Arabic] 
Mihares, S., Raafi’, A., Valek, R. and Chert, J. (1985). Uss Al-Shuruur ‘Ard li Al-Ta’assub Wa Al-Usouliyyah Wa Ikhtilaal Mawazeen Al-Quwa Bayna Al-Jinsayn ‘The Source of Evil A Presentation of Danaticism, Fundamentalism, and the Imbalance of Power between the Sexes’. Cairo: National Center for Translation. [in Arabic] 
Mostafa, A. (2019). Al-Mugalatat Al-Mantiqiyyah Fusoul Fi Al-Mantiq Ghayr Al-Suri ‘Logical Fallacies Chapters in Non-Formal Logic’. 15th edition. Cairo: Vision for Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]
Nicholson, R. (1943). Fi Al-Tasawwuf Al-Islami Wa Tarikhoh ‘In Islamic Mysticism and Its History’. Cairo: Authoring Translation and Publishing House Press. [in Arabic]. 
Shaml, A. (2016). Ruḥi Untha ‘My Soul Is Female’. Cairo: Al-Kutub Khan for Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]
Sherawati, A. (2003). Al-Usus Al-Nazariyyah LiTajribah Al-Diniyyah: Qira’ah Naqdiyyah ‘Theoretical Foundations of Religious Experience: A Critical Reading’. Beirut: Dar Al-Ghadeer. [in Arabic]