Correcting Misconceptions and Enhancement of Reasoning Skills: Simulation-Supported Dual Situated Learning Model

(Adel R. Althubyani)

---

Abstract

This study aimed to explore the effectiveness of using the Simulation-Supported Dual Situated Learning Model (Sim-DSLM) to correct students’ misconceptions, retention, and enhancement of reasoning skills. To address this objective, a quantitative, experimental approach with pre- and post-learning tests was employed. The researcher developed two tests: (1) a physics misconceptions test and (2) a reasoning thinking skills test, which were both checked for validity and reliability. The tests were administered twice, before and after lessons were taught, to 57 participants recruited randomly from the seventh grade in Mecca, Saudi Arabia. The experimental group (30) was taught using the Sim-DSLM and the control group (27) was taught according to the traditional lecture method. The results from both the physics misconceptions test and the reasoning thinking skills test showed that the experimental group statistically scored higher than the control group in the post-learning test. The effective values of using Sim-DSLM to correct students’ misconceptions, retention, and enhancement of reasoning thinking skills were high. The researcher recommends that teachers should be trained to uncover and remediate the misconceptions that students have using strategies such as the Sim-DSLM.
KEYWORDS
DSLM, scientific concepts, simulations, conceptual change, scientific concepts, thinking skills

PDF

References

Abdel Salam, M. (2020). Athar aistikhdam namadhij altadris albinayiyi "wayutlaa - nidham - adaa washayir" fi tanmiat maharat altafkir altawlidii wataswib altasawurat albadilat libaed almafahim alfizyayiyat ladaa tulaab alsafi al'awal althaanawii bialqasimi ‘The effect of using constructive teaching models "Wheatley- Needham- Adey & Shayer" in developing generative thinking skills and correcting the alternative physical concepts among first secondery grade students in Qassim’. The Educational Journal, 35(140), 75–122. [in Arabic] 
Akpinar, E. (2007). The effect of dual situated learning model on students’ understanding of photosynthesis and respiration concepts. Journal of Baltic Science Education, 6(3), 16–26. 
Al-Zoubi, T. and Al-Salam, M.K. (2009). The scientific reasoning level of students’ in the faculty of science in al-hussein bin talal university and its affection of gender, teaching level, and specialization. An-Najah University Journal for Research-B (Humanities), 23(2), 401–37.
Alamoudi, H. (2011). Faeiliat astiratijiat altafkir bisawt murtafie fi tanmiat altafkir alaistidlalii waltahsil fi madat aleulum walaitijah nahw aleamal altaeawunii ladaa tilmidhat almarhalat almutawasitat bialmamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiati ‘The effectiveness of think aloud strategy in developing deductive thinking and academic achievement in science subjects and tendency towards cooperative work among intermediate school female students in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’. Studies in Curriculum and Educational Supervision, 3(1), 193–215. [in Arabic]
Aldahmash, A. and Alashwal, H. (2015). Athar aistikhdam tajarib almuhakaat altafaeuliat fi tashih altasawurat alkhatiat walbadilat limafahim almadat wakhasayisiha wahalatiha ladaa talamidh alsafi alsaabie al'asasii’ The effect of interactive simulated experiments on seventh grade students' alternative and misconceptions of concepts related to some chemistry concepts’. The Arab Journal of Science and Technology Education, n/a (4), 22–46. [in Arabic]
Alhadrami, S. and AmboSaidi, A. (2012). Alealaqat bayn mustawaa altafkir almantiqii ladaa talabat alsafi althaani eashar fi muhafazat aldaakhiliat bisaltanat euman wafahmihim lilmafahim alwirathiati. ‘The relationship between level of inquiry skills and logical thinking abilities among tenth grade Omani students’. An-Najah University Journal of Research, An-Najah National University, 22(4), 595–52. [in Arabic]
Aljamal, A. and Alaqani, A. (2003). Muejam Almustalahat Altarbawiat Almaerifat Fi Almanahij Waturuq Altadrisi’A Glossary of educational terms defined in curricula and teaching methods’. Third edition. Cairo, Egypt: World of Books. [in Arabic]
Alkhouli, M. and Alashwal, H. (2020). Asbab tadaniy natayij talabat alsafi alraabie fi alaikhtibarat alduwaliat TIMSS fi madaris qatar min wijhat nazar muealimayhim’The Reasons of the low results of fourth-grade students in TIMSS international tests in Qatar schools from their teachers' point of view. In: Qatar University Annual Forum and Exhibition, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar, 10/28/2020. [in Arabic]
Almohi, S. and Alshamrani, S. (2016). Mustawaa tadmin maharat alaistiqsa' fi al'anshitat aleamaliat fi muqarar alkimia' lilsafi al'awal althaanawii wawaqie mumaristiha ‘The inclusion and practice of the essential features of inquiry in the scientific activities in Saudi 10th grade chemistry textbooks. Journal of Education and Psychology, n/a(35), 141–70. [in Arabic]
Alosaimi, K. (2015). Athar astikhdam astiratijiat skambir litadris aleulum fi tanmiat altafkir alastidlalii waltanzim aldhaatii walmaharat alhayatiat ladaa tulaab alsafi al'awal almutawasiti ‘Effect of scamper's science teaching strategy on the development of deductive thinking self-regulation and life skills among the first class intermediate students’. Journal of College of Education: Benha University, 29(116), .335–271. [in Arabic]
Alosaimi, K. (2021). Faeiliat namudhaj altaealum thunayiya almawqif (DSLM) fi tadris aleulum ealaa tanmiat almafahim aleilmiat wamaharat ma wara' almaerifat walmuetaqadat almaerifiat ladaa tulaab alsafi althaani almutawasiti’ The Effectiveness of dual situated learning model (dslm) in teaching science on developing scientific concepts, metacognitive skills and epistemological beliefs for students in the second year of intermediate school’. Journal of the Faculty of Education for Educational Sciences, 45(2), 77–152. [in Arabic]
Alshahrani, N. (2018). Faeaaliat tadris aleulum biaistikhdam namudhaji drayfir wafrayir fi tanmiat almafahim walqiam aleilmiat ladaa tulaab alsafi althaani almutawasiti ‘Effectiveness of an integrative counseling program in developing positive dialogue skills in students of college of education in university of bisha’. University of Bisha Journal for Humanities and Educational Sciences, n/a(3), 335–402. [in Arabic]
Alsubaie, M. (2020). Athar aistikhdam wasayil altawasul alaijtimaeii fi tadris aleulum fi tanmiat altahsil aldirasii waltafkir alaistidlalii ladaa tilmidhat alsafi al'awal almutawasit bimadinat makat almukaramati ‘The effect of using social media in teaching science and on developing academic achievement and deductive thinking among seventh grade female students in the city of Mecca Almukramah’. Umm Al-Qura University Journal of Education and Psychology Sciences, 12(3), 4–73. [in Arabic]
Aptyka, H., Fiedler, D. and Großschedl, J. (2022). Effects of situated learning and clarification of misconceptions on contextual reasoning about natural selection. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 15(1), 1–21.
Aryani, W.D., Suhendi, E., Suyana, I., Samsudin, A. and Kaniawati, I. (2019). Effectiveness of implementation interactive conceptual instruction (ICI) with computer simulation to overcome students’ misconceptions about newton’s law of gravitation.  Journal of Physics: Conference Series ,1280)5(, 1–7. 
Bishay, Z. (2019). Astiratijiat muqtarihat qayimat ealaa altaelim almutamayiz wa'anmat altaealum litanmiat maharat altafkir alaistidlalii walnazeat alriyadiat almuntijat ladaa talamidh almarhalat al'iiedadiati ‘A proposed strategy based on differentiated instruction and learning styles to develop deductive thinking skills and productive mathematical disposition for preparatory stage pupils’’. Mathematics Education Journal, 22(9), .114–72. [in Arabic]
Cohen. J. (1992). A power primer. Psychological Bulletin, 112(1), 155–59. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.112.1.155
Cvetković, D. and Birajdar, G. (2020). Numerical Modeling and Computer Simulation. United Kingdom: Intechopen. 
Denyour, Y. (2017). Athar aistikhdam alrihlat almaerifiat eabr alwib (Web Quest) fi tadris alfizia' ealaa altahsil watanmiat maharat altafkir alaistidlalii ladaa talibat alsafi althaani althaanawi ‘The Effect of Using Web Quest Cognitive Journey Strategy in Teaching Physics on Achievement and Developing Deductive Thinking Skills for Second Secondary Grade Students’. Educational and Psychological Studies Faculty of Education Journal Zagazig University, 32(97), 257–331. [in Arabic]
Diani, R., Latifah, S., Jamaluddin, W., Pramesti, A., Susilowati, N.E. and Diansah, I. (2020). Improving students’ science process skills and critical thinking skills in physics learning through fera learning model with savir approach. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1467(1), 12–45.
Diola, J.R.G. and Mistades, V.M. (2021). Addressing students’ misconceptions in force and motion using interactive simulations. In: International Conference on Modern Educational Technology, Jakarta, Indonesia, 21-23/5/2021. 
Dole, S., Bloom, L. and Kowalske, K. (2016). Transforming pedagogy: Changing perspectives from teacher-centered to learner-centered. Interdisciplinary. Journal of Problem-Based Learning, 10(1), 7–31. 
Education and Training Evaluation Commission. (2020). TIMSS 2019 Report. First Insight into Mathematics and Science Acheivments of Saudi Arabia Students in Grade 4 and 8 in an International Context. 
Eymur, G. and Geban, Ö. (2017). The collaboration of cooperative learning and conceptual change: Enhancing the students’ understanding of chemical bonding concepts. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 15(5), 853–71.
Fratiwi, N.J., Kaniawati, I., Suhendi, E., Suyana, I. and Samsudin, A. (2017). The transformation of two-tier test into four-tier test on Newton’s laws concepts. In: AIP Conference Proceedings, 30/5/2017. 
Gurel, D.K., Eryilmaz, A. and McDermott, L.C. (2015). A review and comparison of diagnostic instruments to identify students’ misconceptions in science. Eurasia Journal of Mathematics, Science and Technology Education, 11(5), 989–1008.
Hwa, T.H. and Karpudewan, M. (2017). Green chemistry-based dual-situated learning model: An approach that reduces students’ misconceptions on acids and bases. In:  M. Karpudewan, A. Nurulazam, and A. Chandrasegaran (eds.) Overcoming Students' Misconceptions in Science: Strategies and Perspectives from Malaysia. Singapore, Springer. 
Kaniawati, I., Fratiwi, N.J., Danawan, A., Suyana, I., Samsudin, A. and Suhendi, E. (2019). Analyzing students' misconceptions about newton's laws through four-tier newtonian test (FTNT). Journal of Turkish Science Education, 16(1), 110–22.
Khawaldeh, S. (2015). Athar namudhaj altaealum thunayiya almawqif fi fahm mafahim albina' aldawyiyi waltanafus ladaa talib alsafi altaasie al'asasii walaihtifaz bihadha alfahma ‘The impact of the two-way learning model on understanding and retention of the concepts of photosynthesis and respiration among ninth basic grade students’. Al-Manarah for Research and Studies, 21(2), .464–23. [in Arabic]
Kurniawan, M.A., Rahayu, S., Fajaroh, F. and Almuntasheri, S. (2020). Effectiveness of dual situated learning model in improving high school students' conceptions of chemistry equilibrium and preventing their misconceptions. Journal of Science Learning, 3(2), 99–105.
Liu, G. and Fang, N. (2016). Student misconceptions about force and acceleration in physics and engineering mechanics education. International Journal of Engineering Education, 32(1), 19–29.
Macabebe, E.Q.B., Culaba, I.B. and Maquiling, J.T. (2010). Pre‐conceptions of newton’s laws of motion of students in introductory physics. In: AIP Conference Proceedings, 5/8/2010. 
Mashi, K and Aljabr, J. (2019). Mustawaa tadmin simat alaistiqsa' aleilmii fi 'anshitat taqwim al'ada' fi dalil muealim aleulum liltaqwim fi almarhalatayn alaibtidayiyat walmutawasitat bialmamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiati’ Inclusion level of scientific inquiry features in performance assessment activities in science teacher's assessment guidebook for elementary and intermediate schools in Saudi Arabia’. Journal of Educational Sciences, 32(1), 173–96. [in Arabic]
Obafemi, D.T. and Aderonmu, T.S. (2022). Identification and sources of misconceptions held by secondary school physics students in heat energy in rivers state, Nigeria. European Journal of Education Studies, 9(4), 120–33.
OECD. (2018). Country Note: Program For International Student Assessment (PISA) Results. From PISA 2018.
Olympiou, G., Zacharias, Z. and Dejong, T. (2013). Making the invisible visible: Enhancing students’ conceptual understanding by introducing representations of abstract objects in a simulation. Instructional Science, 41(3), 575–96.
Othman, M. (2021). Aistikhdam Altaealum Thunayiyi Almawqif Litanmiat Maharat Altafkir Alta'amulii Waltahsil Fi Alkimia' ladaa Tulaab Almarhalat Althaanawiati ‘The use of two-situational learning to develop reflective thinking skills and achievement in chemistry among secondary school students. Master ‘s Thesis, Damietta University, Egypt. [in Arabic]
Poutot, G. and Blandin, B. (2015). Exploration of students’ misconceptions in mechanics using the FCI. American Journal of Educational Research, 3(2), 116–20.
Ramesh, M. (2018). A study on status of inference skills inn science among VIII standards students. International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology, 6(1), 423–7. 
Rutten, N., Van Joolingen, W.R. and Van Der Veen, J.T. (2012). The learning effects of computer simulations in science education. Computers and education, 58(1), 136–53.
Senthilkumar, R.D., Vimala, E. and Al-Ruqeishi, E. (2014). Use of ICT with dual situated learning model in physics education. In: 2nd International Conference on Applied Information and Communications Technology, Muscat, Oman, 28-29/4/2014.
She, H.C. (2002). Concepts of a higher hierarchical level require more dual situated learning events for conceptual change: a study of air pressure and buoyancy. International Journal of Science Education, 24(9), 981–96.
She, H.C. (2004). Fostering radical conceptual change through dual‐situated learning model. Journal of Research in Science Teaching: The Official Journal of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, 41(2), 142–64.
She, H.C. and Liao, Y.W. (2010). Bridging scientific reasoning and conceptual change through adaptive web‐based learning. Journal of Research in Science Teaching: The Official Journal of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching, 47(1), 91–119.
Srisawasdi, N. and Kroothkeaw, S. (2014). Supporting students’ conceptual development of light refraction by simulation-based open inquiry with dual-situated learning model. Journal of Computers in Education, 1(1), 49–79.
Strike, K. and Posner, G. (1985). A conceptual change view of learning and understanding. Cognitive Structure and Conceptual Change, n/a(n/a) , 189–210.
Wartono, D.H. and Nilasari, J. R. B. (2019). Real-virtual monte carlo simulation on impulse-momentum and collisions. Indonesian Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 13(1), 7–14.
Zimmerman, C. (2005). The development of scientific reasoning skills: What psychologists contribute to an understanding of elementary science learning. Final draft of a report to the National Research Council Committee on science learning kindergarten through eight grade. Washington, Dc, National Research Council.