Orientalists’ Views on the Arabs of the Arabian Peninsula: A Critical Enquiry into the Journey of William Palgrave

(Khlaif S. Alshammari)

---

Abstract

This article sheds light on how the Arabs of the Arabian Peninsula are described in the writings of the English orientalist William Gifford Palgrave (1826-1888). He depicted a lively and vibrant social image of the inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula. He wrote about their religious, intellectual, moral, political and social aspects. He relied on his travelling throughout the Peninsula to discuss this society, its characteristics, its positives and its negatives. The study investigates the stereotyped image of these Arabs in line with Orientalist experiments specifically in the 19th century. It adopts historical and comparative approaches within his writings away from exaggeration in interpretation. It reveals the dominance of Eurocentrism as a conceptual framework that has had an impact on most of his writings, just like other orientalists in the 19th century.
KEYWORDS
Arab characteristics, eurocentrism, historical approach, orientalism

PDF

References

Abu Alayhi, A.H. (1999). Tarikh Al-Dawlah Al-Saudia Al-Thaniyah 1256-1309AH/1840-1891AD ‘History of the Second Saudi State 1256-1309AH/1840-1891AD’. 6th edition. Riyadh: Dar Al-Mirrikh. [in Arabic]
Al-Askar, A. (2002). Rihlat Palgrave muearaba ‘Palgrave journey by localization’. Al-Riyadh Newspaper, n/a(12385), n/a. [in Arabic]
Al-Askar, A. (2002). Rihlat Palgrave muearaba ‘Palgrave journey by localization’. Al-Riyadh Newspaper, n/a(12399), n/a. [in Arabic]
Al-ʻAwwami, A.A. (2011). Tarjamat riḥlat Palgrave: Tarjamat tḥtaj ila tarjamat ‘Translation of Belgrave's journey: A translation that needs translation’. Majallat Al-Waḥah Al-Iliktruniyah, 16(60), n/a. http://www.alwahamag.com [in Arabic]
Al-Khalidi, D.A. (2014). Al-Aḥsa Fi Riḥlat William Palgrave (1862-1863m/1279-1280h) ‘Al-Ahsa in the Journey of William Palgrave (1862-1863AD/1279-1280AH)’. Cairo: Ḥawliyat Al-Muaarrikh Al-Miṣri, Cairo University. [in Arabic]
Al-Muṭawwar, A.A. (2009). Al-Anbaṭ: Tarikh Wa-Ḥaḍarah ‘The Nabataeans: History and Civilization’. Amman: Dar Usamah. [in Arabic]
Al-Shammari, K. (2014). Jabal Shammar Fi Ahd Ṭalal Al-Abdallh Al-Rashid: Dirasah Siyasiyah ‘The Shammar Mountain in the Era of Talal Al-Abdullah Al-Rasheed: A Political and Civilized Study’. Buraydah: Al-Qaṣim University. [in Arabic]
Al-Shammari, K. (2016). Ṭalal Ibn Allah Al Rashid 1238-1283H/1822-1867M Qiraah Susiyu-Tarikhiyah ‘Talal Bin Abdullah Al Rashid 1238-1283AH/1822-1867AD Socio-historical Reading’. Beirut: Jadawil. [in Arabic]
Al-Sunaydi, S.M. (2009). Al-Qaṣim Fi Riḥlat William Palgrave (1279h/1862m) "ʻarḍ Wa-Dirasa" ‘Al-Qassim in the Journey of William Palgrave (1279AH/1862AD) "Exposition and Study"’. Riyadh: Al-Jamiyah Al-Tarikhiyah Al-Saudiyah. [in Arabic] 
Al-Ẓahiri, A.A. (1994). Masail Min Tarikh Al-Jazirah Al-Arabiyah ‘Questions from the History of the Arabian Island’. 4th edition. Riyadh: Muassasat Dar Al-Aṣalah. [in Arabic]
Al-Zulfah, M.A. (2014). Ḥaʼil Fi Kitab Al-Raḥḥalah William Palgrave 1279-1862M ‘Hail in the Book of the Traveler William Palgrave in 1279-1862 AD’. 2nd edition. Riyadh: Dar Bilad Al-Arab. [in Arabic]
Ataallh, S. (1998). Qafilat Al-Ḥibr Al-Raḥḥalah Al-Gharbiyun Ila Al-Jazirah Al-Arabiyah (1762-1950) ‘Ink Caravan Western Travelers to Arabian Island (1762-1950)’. 2nd edition. Beirut: Dar Al-Saqi. [in Arabic] 
Awbnhaym, M., Wʼrsh, B. and Caskel, W. (2007). Al-Badw ‘Bedouins’. 2nd edition. Beirut: Dar Al-Warraq. [in Arabic]
Barudi, B. (2012). Palgrave Wnoqadoh: Uṣūl Al-Jadal Wa Maḍamynoh ‘Palgrave and its critics: The origins of the controversy and its contents’. Riyadh: Dar Bilad Al-Arab. [in Arabic]
Biduwal R. (1989). Alrraḥalh Al-Gharbiyūn Fi Al-Jazirah Al-Arabiyah ‘Western Travelers in Arabian Island’. Riyadh: King Saud Univeristy Press. [in Arabic]
Birayn, J. (n/a). Iktishaf Jazirat Al-Arab Khamsat Qurūn Min Al-Mughamarah Wal-ʻilm ‘Discover Arabian Island Five Centuries of Adventure and Science’. Beirut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi. [in Arabic]
Blunt, A.A. (2005). Riḥlah Ila Najd Mahd Al-ʻashaʼir Al-ʻArabiyah ‘A Trip to Najd the Cradle of the Arab Clans’. Dimashq: Al-Mada. [in Arabic]
Blunt, W.S. (1880). A Visit to Jebel Shammar (Nejd). New Routes through Northern and Central Arabia. In: Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society and Monthly Record of Geography, 2(2), 81–102. DOI: 10.2307/1800398
Blunt, W.S. (1882). The Future of Islam. London: Kegan Paul.
Cromer, C. (1908). Modern Egypt. London: Macmillan and Co., Limited. 
Didier, C. (2007). Rihlat 'Iilaa Rihab Alsharif Al'akbar Sharif Makah Almukaramah Fi Alnisf Althaani Min Alqarn Altaasie Ashar Almiladii 1854M ‘A Trip to Rehab Al-Sharif Al-Akbar, Sharif of Makkah Al-Mukarramah in the Second Half of the Nineteenth Century 1854AD’. 2nd edition. Beirut: Aldaar Al-Arabiah.
Falyn, J.U. (2009). Riḥlat Falyn Ila Jazirat Al-Arab ‘The Falyn Trips to Arabian Island’. 2nd edition. Beirut: Dar Al-Warraq. [in Arabic]
Filbi, H.S. (2002). Ayyam Arabiyah ‘An Arab Days’. Riyadh: Maktabat Al-Ubaykan. [in Arabic]
Filbi, H.S. (2009). Qalb Al-Jazirah Al-Arabiyah Sijill Al-Asfar Walestkshaf ‘The Center of Arabia A Record of Travels and Exploration’. 2nd edition. Cairo: Al-Markaz Al-Qawmi lil-Tarjamah. [in Arabic]
Ghwrmany, C.K. (2009). Najd Eshshamalee: Riḥlat Min Al-Quds Ila Unayzah Fi Al-Qaṣim Aam 1864M ‘Northern Najd: A Trip from Jerusalem to Unaizah in Al-Qassim in 1864 AD’. Abu Dhabi: Dar al-Kutub Al-Waṭaniyah. [in Arabic]
Hachicho, M.A. (1964). English Travel Books about the Arab near East in the Eighteenth Century. Die Welt Des Islams, 9(1/4), 1–206. DOI: 10.2307/1570430 
Hogarth, D.G. (2009). Airtiad Jazirat Alearab Sirat Kshuf Rahaalat Algharb Wamughamaratihim Fi 'Ard Aljazirati ‘Going to the Arabian Island, A Biography of Western Travelers' Discoveries and their Adventures in the Land of the Island’. Abu Dhabi: Abu Dhabi Authority for Culture and Heritage. [in Arabic]
Ian, B.R. (2002). The medicalization of sovereignty: Medicine, public health, and political authority in Syria, 1861–1936. Stanford University: ProQuest Dissertations Publishing.
Ibrahim, A.A. (2013). Riwayat Gharbiah an Riḥlat Fi Shibh Al-Jazirah Al-ʻArabiyah ‘Western Narratives on Travels in the Arabian Peninsula’. Beirut: Dar Al-Saqi. [in Arabic]
Idward S. (2005). Al-Istishraq, Al-Maʻrifah, Al-Sulṭah ‘Orientalism, Knowledge, Power’. 3rd edition. Beirut: Muʼassasat Al-Abḥath Al-Arabia. [in Arabic] 
Jabbur J.S. (1988). Al-Badw Wal-Badiyah: Ṣuwar Min Ḥayat Al-Badw Fi Badiyat Al-Sham ‘Bedouins and the Badia: Pictures from the Life of the Bedouins in the Badia of Al-Sham’. Beirut: Dar Al-Ilm lil-Malayin. [in Arabic]
Jawdah, W. and Al-Ḥimyari T. (2018). Falsafat al-fikr al-dini li-jamiyat al-yasuiyin (Aljwzyt) 1534–1556m ‘Philosophy of religious thought of the society of the Jesuits (Jesuits) 1534–1556AD’. In: The Third Scientific Conference of the College of Arts, and the First Annual Conference of the Department of Philosophy (By Philosophy and Human Sciences We Raise Religious Awareness), College of Arts, University of Baghdad, 26/04/2018, 559–74. DOI: 10.31973/aj.v1iSpecial is.525 [in Arabic]
Kishk, M.J. (1984). Al-Saudiyun Wa Al-Ḥall Al-Islami: Maṣdar Al-Shariyah Lil-Niẓam Al-Saudi ‘The Saudis and the Islamic Solution: The Source of Legitimacy for the Saudi Constitution’. 4th edition. Cairo: Al-Maṭbaah Al-Fanniyah. [in Arabic] 
Mandler, D. (2016). Arminius Vambéry and the British Empire: Between East and West Hardcover. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books.
Meyerhof, M. (1930). The “Book of Treasure”, an Early Arabic Treatise on Medicine. Isis the History of Science Society, 14(1), 55–76. http://www.jstor.org/stable/224380 
Ministry of Foreign Affairs. (1862). Sanad Nemrah 596 ‘Instrument Number 596’. Archive of the Iranian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Tehran. [in Arabic]
Palgrave, W.G. (1864). Observations made in central, eastern, and southern Arabia during a journey through that country in 1862 and 1863. The Journal of the Royal Geographical Society of London, 34(n/a), 111–54. DOI: 10.2307/1798469 
Palgrave, W.G. (2012). Wasaṭ Al-Jazirah Al-ʻArabiyah Wa Shrqha ‘Central and Eastern Arabian Island’. Cairo: Al-Majlis Al-Ala Li-Thaqafah. [in Arabic]
Shaz, R. (2007). Al-Ṭariq Ila Al-Jazirah Al-Arabiyah ‘The road to Arabian Island’, Beirut: Al-Dar Al-ʻArabiyah Lil-Mawsuat. [in Arabic]
Taylwr, B. (2012). Al-Tirḥal Fi Wasaṭ Al-Jazirah Al-ʻArabiyah ‘Traveling in the Middle of the Arabian Island’. Abu Dhabi: Dar Al-Kutub Al-Waṭaniyah. [in Arabic]