Planning of Urban Quarters, Districts and Neighbourhoods in Islam’s Holiest City: A Comparative Analytical Study

(Abdo Absi, Adel M. Binyaseen and Abdulghani Monawar)

---

Abstract

Global experiences of planning urban areas are characterised by adopting hierarchical structures from large to small structures, i.e. residential quarter (large residential area), residential district and then residential neighbourhood. Each structure is characterised according to the area, the number of people and the services required for targeting a sustainable urban environment. This concept is a milestone in urban planning in Saudi Arabia. The research attempted to discuss the general trend of planning housing projects in Saudi Arabia and the extent of applying the hierarchal concept. Three models were chosen randomly in Makkah, showing such planning hierarchy. These are Al Shawqiyyah, Al Sharaie and Al Rabwah. These projects were planned four decades ago and became a reality. Through comparative analytical methods, findings revealed ambiguity of the hierarchal planning concept in these projects. Further, the traditional neighbourhood concept was prevalent in most neighbourhoods characterised by low-density development in planning but medium and high densities in reality. The problem is getting worse as cities grow horizontally and vertically. Consistent scientific analysis based on practice and continuous meta-analysis was used. The paper calls for the need to change the current premises of housing plans and reorganise the accumulated problems according to global experiences and local standards.

KEYWORDS
Hierarchical structure, housing, urban planning, services, planning standards, land use

PDF

References

Al Absi, A.T. (2009). Takhtit mudun janub sharq 'asya wamadiy alaistifadat minha- alsiyn namudhaju, almaeayir waltatbiqati 'Planning the cities of Southeast Asia and the extent to which it is benefited - China Model, Standards and Applications. Journal of the Yemeni Engineer. 1(2), 38–51. [in Arabic]
Al Absi, A. and Monawar, A. (2020). Takhtit almanatiq alsakaniat bimadinat makat almukaramatu 'Planning of residential areas in Makkah Al-Mukkaramah'. In Second International Engineering Conference and Exhibition, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 2–5/3/2020. [in Arabic]
Al Dardiri, D.H.M. (2013). Almaeayir altakhtitiat litahqiq albued al'iinsanii bialmadinat alearabiat-alhalat aldirasiat madinat alkhobar ' Planning standards to achieve the human dimension in the Arab city - case study of Al Khobar city'. Journal of King Saud University: Architecture and Planning, 25(2), 115–67. [in Arabic] 
Al Majrashi, A. and Al Absi, A. (2020). Dirasat muqaranat bayn takhtit almujawarat alsakaniat wawaqie tanfidhiha, mukhatat alrabwat bimadinat makat almukaramat namudhaju 'A comparative study between the planning of residential neighborhoods and the reality of its implementation, Al-Rabwa scheme in the city of Makkah Al-Mukarramah as a model. Umm Al-Qura University Journal of Engineering and Architecture, 11(2), 48–56. [in Arabic]
Al Shadi, W.A. (2008). Alshaqat alsakaniat kanamat 'iiskan lileayilat alsaeudiati: madkhal litaysir al'iiskan 'Apartment as a housing pattern for the Saudi family: An Introduction to facilitate housing'. In Second Symposium on Affordable Housing, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 28–30/4/2008. [in Arabic]
Chinese Urban Planning Standards. (2004). Chinese Urban Planning Standards. Beijing: Publishing House Architectural Books.
Cindy, F. (2019). Taqyim Mashrueat Alaskan fi Almamlakat Alearabiat Alsaeudiat fi Daw' Almawruth Althaqafii Walajtimaeii Walbiyiyi- Dirasat Muqaranati, 'Evaluation of housing projects in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in light of the cultural, social and environmental legacy - a comparative study'. Master thesis, Umm Al Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia. [in Arabic].
Granottier, B. Translation: Al Fadali, A.B. (1987). Al'iiskan Alhadariu , Alsakan Alhadariu fi Alealam Althaalith Almushkilat Walhulul  'Urban Housing in the Third World, Problems and Solutions. Alexandria, Egypt: Al Maarif Printing, Publishing & distribution. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. (1975). Mukhatat 'Ard Alshawqiati ' Al Shawqiah Land Scheme', Makkah Al-Mukarramah, Saudi Arabia: Municipality of Holy Capital, General Administration of Urban Planning. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. (1982). Mukhatat Sharayie Almujahidina- Mukhatat Raqm 3 'Sharia Mujahideen Scheme - Scheme No. 3', Makkah Al-Mukarramah, Saudi Arabia: Municipality of Holy Capital, General Administration of Urban Planning. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. (1986). Mukhatat Alrabwati 'Al-Rabwa Scheme', Makkah Al-Mukarramah, Saudi Arabia: Municipality of Holy Capital, General Administration of Urban Planning. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. (2005). Dalil Takhtit Marakiz Alahya' Walmujawarat alsakaniati 'Planning Guide for Neighborhood Centers and Residential Neighborhoods', Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Ministry Agency for city Planning, 3–14. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Municipal and Rural Affairs. (2016). Aedad Almaeayir Altakhtitiat Lilkhadamat Aleamat Al'iiqlimiat Walmahaliyat Wamustawayatiha Almukhtalifati: Mulakhas Almaeayir Altakhtitiat Almutawarat Lilkhadamati 'Preparing Planning Standards for Regional and Local Public Services and their Different Levels: Summary of Developed Planning Standards for Services', Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Ministry Agency for city Planning, 6–30. [in Arabic]
Moussa, M.A. (n/a). Muhadarat fi Altakhtit Aleumrani 'lectures in Urban Planning'. Assuit, Egypt: Assiut University Press. [in Arabic]
Tao, S.L., Zip, H.G. and Shou, B.S. (2002). Theories of City Planning. 3rd edition. Wuhan, China: Wuhan Architecture Institute.
The Urban Observatory of Makkah. (2010). Natayij Almuashirat Alhadariat Li'iihya' Makat Almukaramat Nahw Biyat Hadariat Afdil 'The results of urban indicators for the revival of Makkah Al Mukarramah towards a better urban environment. Makkah, Saudi Arabia: Holly Capital Municipality, 34–5. [in Arabic]