Editorial: Nine Suggestions for Improving the Field of Giftedness in the Arab World

(Abdulrahman Essa Al Lily , Abdelrahim Fathy Ismail and Fathi Mohammed Abunasser)

---

Abstract

This editorial problematises the field of giftedness in the Arab world, with the intention of taking all those involved outside their ‘comfort zone’. First, it is advised that Arabs should stop being submissive followers of Western literature (and thus remaining in an inferior cognitive position) and should rather be proactive and leading contributors to worldviews. Second, research on Arab giftedness should be contextualised and ‘culturalised’ by investigating the long-overlooked Arab-specific influences on gifted people. Third, there is a need to tackle the issue of ‘word stuffing’ and to instead promote efficiency in academic writing, bearing in mind that Arab academic writers habitually employ many words and sentences that contain few or even no meanings. Fourth, awareness campaigns and regulations should be initiated to restrict the deeply rooted ‘copy-and-paste’ culture, whereby many Arab academics copy (frankly, steal) from one another, resulting in considerable plagiarism and repetition. Fifth, researchers should dare to expose the field (and their datasets) to the cultural ‘taboo’ of genuinely critically reflective thinking. Sixth, it needs to be accepted that giftedness practitioners lack qualifications, as a result of which they tend to act spontaneously, with no academic basis. Seventh, some Arab institutions display an interest in the nurture of gifted students not for the sake of the gifted themselves but rather to look ‘cool’ and to polish their own public image. Eighth, the ideologically intense nature of the wider culture leads many researchers to emphasise certainty and ‘truth’, even though ‘doubt’ is the bedrock of academia. Last, giftedness should be institutionalised in tertiary education (as is the case in secondary education); as things stand, gifted university students miss out on the nurture they experienced at secondary school. It is hoped that these nine points will be regarded as a starting point for the philosophical foundation of an ‘Arab Critical School of Thought’.

KEYWORDS
Arab giftedness, Arab talentedness, Arab creativity, Arab excellence, talented policies, creativity policies, Arab culture, Arab research, Arab literature, reflection, criticism

PDF

References

Abdin, S. (2020). Munasiq almawhubin fi daw' alruwyati ‘The gifted coordinator, in light of the Saudi Vision 2030’. In: The First National Symposium for Talented Coordinators, the National Research Centre for Giftedness and Creativity, King Faisal University, Al Ahsa, Saudi Arabia. 4-5/03/2020. [in Arabic]
Abu Ghamjah, N.M. (2016). Hijrat aleuqul alearabiati 'Migration of Arab minds'. Journal of Science and Technology, 17(1) n/a. [in Arabic]
Al Aesaru, S. and Kafafi, A. (2000). Emotional Intelligence ‘Aldhika' Alwajdani’. Cairo: Qabaa Printing and Publishing House. [in Arabic]
Al Lily, A. E., Alhazmi, A. A. and Alzahrani, S. (2017). The theory of multiple stupidities: Education, technology and organisation in Arabia. Cognitive Processing, 18(4), 529–41.
Al-Arwi, Abdullah. (1970). Al'iidyulujiaa Alearabiat Almueasiratu 'Contemporary Arab Ideology'. Beirut: Dar Al Talei '. [in Arabic]
Al-Dalbahi, A.K.. (2020). Tajribat jamieat almalik sueud fi rieayat almawhubina ‘King Saud University’s Experience with the Nurturance of the Gifted’. In: The First National Symposium for Talented Coordinators, the National Research Centre for Giftedness and Creativity, King Faisal University, Al Ahsa, Saudi Arabia. 4-5/03/2020. [in Arabic]
Al-Jabri, M.A. (1989). Iishkaliaat Alfikr Alearabii Almaeasiru ‘Problems of Contemporary Arab Thought’. Beirut: Centre for Arab Unity Studies. [in Arabic]
Aljughaiman, A. (2008). Tarbiat almawhubin fi alealam alearabi ‘Educating the Gifted in the Arab World’. The Sixth Conference of Arab Ministers of Education, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 01–02/03/2008. [in Arabic]
Al-Khani, R. (2015). Muhadaratan Mafhum Almawhibat Alkadhiba ‘Lecture on the Concept of False Talent’. Available at: https://www.alukah.net/social/0/91570/ (accessed on 27/07/2020) [in Arabic]
Al-Marzouqi, M.A. (2001). Tajliat Alfalsifat Alearabiati ‘The Manifestations of Arab Philosophy’. Beirut: House of Contemporary Thought. [in Arabic]
Muammar, O.M. (2017). Anmiat almiharaat alqiadiat lilmawahib alshshabat bijamieat al'imam eabd alruhmin bin fysl: namudhaj 'iithrayiyun muqtarah 'Developing leadership skills for young talents at Imam Abdul Rahman bin Faisal University: A proposed enrichment model. The Fourth Scientific Forum “Talent between Public Education and Higher Education: Integration and Continuity”, the National Research Centre for Giftedness and Creativity, King Faisal University, Al Ahsa, Saudi Arabia, 13-14/03/2017. [in Arabic]
Al-Nafi, A. (2016). Almuhibat Tasnae Alhidar 'Talent Builds Civilization'. Medina: Hanakiyah Education Agency. [in Arabic]
Alsamadi, H.A. and Alghazw, I.M. (2018). Athar altihaq altalabat almawhubin bimadaris almalik eabdallah alththani liltamayuz fi takiufihim alaijtimaeii bimuhafazat 'iirbid 'The effect of gifted students attending King Abdullah II Schools of Excellence in their social adaptation in Irbid Governorate’. Al-Fateh Magazine, 14(75), 60–81. [in Arabic]
Arkoun, M. (1985). Alfikr Alearabi 'Arab Thought'. Beirut: Aouidat Publications. [in Arabic]
Clinton, A. 2020. Tahadiyat Munsaqi Almawhubina ‘Challenges of Talented Coordinators’. In: The First National Symposium for Talented Coordinators, the National Research Centre for Giftedness and Creativity, King Faisal University, Al Ahsa, Saudi Arabia. 04–05/03/2020. [in Arabic]
Maeajini, O.H.M. (2008). Altajarib alraayidat erbyaan wdwlyaan fi tarbiat almawhubin warieayatihima: rieayat almawhubina: khiar almunafasat al'afdali 'Arab and international pioneering experiences in raising and caring for the talented: Caring for the talented is the best competition option'. The Sixth Arab Ministers of Education Conference, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. [in Arabic]
Khader, A.F. (1981). Azmat Albahth Aleilmii fi Alealam Alearabi 'The Crisis of Scientific Research in the Arab World'. Riyadh: Institute of Public Administration. [in Arabic]
Massad, J. (2013). Aishtiha' Alearab ‘Desiring Arabs’. Cairo: Dar Al Shorouk. [in Arabic]
Sabilana, M. 2009. Mudarat Alhadathati ‘The Orbits of Modernity’. Beirut: Arab Network for Research and Publishing. [in Arabic]
Selwyn, N. (2012). Ten suggestions for improving academic research in education and technology. Learning, Media and Technology, 37(3), 213–9.
Tarabishi, G. (2007). Nazariat Aleaql Alearabi 'The Arab Mind Theory'. London: Dar al-Saqi. [in Arabic]
Tawfiq, S. (2007). Azmat Al'iibdae fi Thuqafatina Almueasirati ‘The Crisis of Creativity in our Contemporary Culture’. Beirut: Almuasasat Aljamieiat Lildirasat Walnashr Waltawziei. [in Arabic]
Yamin, T.S. (2009). Tarbiat Almawhubin fi Albayyaat Alaiftiradiati 'Educating the Gifted in Virtual Environments'. Jordan, Amman: The Arab Network for Open and Distance Education. [in Arabic]