The Role of Digital Skills Exercises in Developing Higher- Level Thinking Skills

(Adel Musaad Alrasheedi and Abdulaziz Abdullah Alfayez)

---

Abstract

Developing students’ higher-order thinking skills is a fundamental goal of modern education, as it contributes to preparing a generation capable of analysis, evaluation, and creativity. In this context, the current study aimed to examine the extent to which the exercises in the Digital Skills textbook for the second intermediate grade contribute to the development of higher-order thinking skills according to the revised Bloom’s taxonomy. For this purpose, the researchers employed the descriptive-analytical method using content analysis, and prepared a content analysis checklist to evaluate the exercises in the Digital Skills textbooks approved by the Saudi Ministry of Education for the three semesters of the academic year 2023/2024. The results showed that the textbook exercises largely focused on lower-order thinking levels (remembering, understanding, and applying) at a rate of (94.21%), with 293 questions. The highest percentage of these levels appeared in the second semester (96.43%), followed by the third semester (96.2%), and the first semester (91.9%). In contrast, higher-order thinking levels (analyzing, evaluating, and creating) received little attention, accounting for only 5.8% with 18 questions. The highest percentage of these levels appeared in the first semester (8.1%), followed by the third semester (3.8%), and the second semester (3.57%). The findings revealed statistically significant differences between the lower- and higher-order thinking levels in favor of higher-order skills. 
KEYWORDS
Computer education, digital skills, educational evaluation, intermediate stage, revised bloom’s taxonomy, curriculum exercises

PDF

References

Ahmed, K. (2017). Tahlil muhtawaa kitab alhasub lisanat 2017 lilsafi al'awal al'iiedadii wfqan lieidat maeayiri ‘Content analysis of the 2017 computer science book for the first year of middle school according to several standards’. Journal of Educational Studies, 5(1), 45–6. [in Arabic]
Ahmed, M. (2020). Tahlil al'asyilat altaqwimiat fi kitab alhasib alali lilsafi althaamin al'asasii fi daw' mustawayat bilum lilmajal almaerifii ‘Analysis of the assessment questions in the computer textbook for the eighth grade in light of Bloom's levels of the cognitive domain’. Journal of Educational Sciences Studies, 49(2), 67. [in Arabic]
Al-‘Amoush, A. (2020). Taḥlīl 'asyilat ikhtibārāt al-shahādah al-asāsiyyah al-‘āmmah limāddat tikanulūjiyā al-ma‘lumāt bi-al-Jumhūriyyah al-Yamaniyyah lil-‘ām al-dirāsī 2019 fī ḍaw’ taṣnīf Bloom lil-ahdāf al-ma‘rifiyyah ‘Analysis of general basic certificate examination questions in the subject of information technology in the Republic of Yemen for the academic year 2019 in light of Bloom’s taxonomy of cognitive objectives’. Al-Qalam University Journal for Humanities and Applied Sciences, n/a(n/a), n/a. [in Arabic]
Al-Assaf, S.H. (2015). Al-Madkhal ila al-Baḥth fī al-‘Ulūm al-Sulūkīyah ‘Introduction to Research in Behavioral Sciences’, 4nd. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Dar Al-Zahra for Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]
Al-Ghamlas, O.A. (2023). Taqwīm maqarr al-mahārāt al-raqamiyyah bi-al-marḥalah al-mutawassiṭah wafq taṣnīf Bloom fī ḍaw’ ma‘āyīr ta‘allum al-tiknūlūjiyā al-raqamiyyah fī al-Mamlakah al-‘Arabiyyah al-Su‘ūdiyyah ‘Evaluation of the digital skills curriculum at the intermediate stage according to Bloom’s taxonomy in light of digital technology learning standards in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’. World of Education Journal, 59(5), 185–230. [in Arabic]
Al-Hamidawi, Y. (2020). Mawsueat Mustalahat Almanahiji ‘Encyclopedia of Curriculum Terminology’. Egypt: Dar Al-Sahab. [in Arabic]
Al-Hussain, Ahmed. (2017). Sinaeat Alkitaab Almadrasi ‘Textbook Production’. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Imam Muhammad ibn Saud Islamic University. [in Arabic]
Al-Mashaqbah, F. (2017). Taqwīm Al-Anšiṭah Al-Mutadamanah Fī Kutub Al-Ḥāsūb Lil-Marḥalah Al-Asāsiyyah Al-‘Ulyā Min Wijhat Naẓar Al-Mu‘Allimīn Fī Muḥāfaẓat Al-Mafraq Fī Al-‘Urdun ‘Evaluation of the Activities Included in Computer Textbooks for The Upper Basic Stage from the Teachers’ Perspectives in Mafraq Governorate in Jordan’. Master’s Thesis. Faculty of Educational Sciences, Al al-Bayt University, Jordan. [in Arabic]
Al-Salameen, A. (2021). Tahlil 'asyilat amtihan alshahadat althaanawiat aleamat limadat allughat al'iinjiliziat fi al'urduni lil'aewam 2016-2018 m wafq mustawayat bilum almaerifiat almueadalati ‘Analysis of the general secondary certificate examination questions for the English language subject in Jordan for the years 2016-2018 ad according to bloom’s modified cognitive levels’. Al-Hussein Bin Talal University Journal of Research. 22(7). 91–114. [in Arabic]
Al-Shammari, Z.H. (2005). Madā tarkīz 'asyilat kutub al-lughah al-‘Arabiyyah lil-saff al-awwal mutawassiṭ ‘ala tanmiyat mahārāt al-tafkīr ‘ind al-ṭālibāt ḥasb taṣnīf Bloom lil-ahdāf al-ma‘rifiyyah ‘The extent to which Arabic language textbooks questions for the first intermediate grade focus on developing students’ thinking skills according to Bloom’s taxonomy of cognitive objectives’. Journal of Studies in Curricula and Teaching Methods, n/a(107), 94–141. [in Arabic]
Al-Shurafat, M. (2020). Darajat muraeāt 'asyilat ikhtibar althaanawiat aleamat "al-Tawjihi" limabahith al-fizya' limustawayat bilum alma‘rifiyyah khilal al'a‘wam 2015–2019 fi al-'Urdun ‘The degree of considering the general secondary examination “Tawjihi” questions in physics subject for Bloom’s cognitive levels during the years 2015–2019 in Jordan’. Journal of Educational and Psychological Sciences: National Research Center – Gaza, 22(4), 47–64. [in Arabic]
Al-Suwayrki, M. (2019). Taḥlīl al-asyilah fī kitāb al-lughah al-‘Arabiyyah lil-ṣaff al-awwal thānawī fī al-Mamlakah al-‘Arabiyyah al-Su‘ūdiyyah wafq taṣnīf Bloom limustawayāt al-ahdāf al-ma‘rifiyyah ‘Analysis of the questions in the Arabic language textbook for the first secondary grade in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia according to Bloom’s taxonomy of cognitive objectives’. Journal of Scientific Research in Education, n/a(20), 585–602. [in Arabic]
Al-Tawaiha, F.D. (2012). Tahlil Al'asyilat Altaqyimiat Almaerifiat Almutadamanat Fi Kutub Allughat Alearabiat Lilsafi Althaamin Al'asasii Fi Al'urduni ‘Analysis of Cognitive Assessment Questions Included in Arabic Language Textbooks for The Eighth Grade in Jordan’. Master's Thesis. Mu'tah University, Jordan. [in Arabic]
Anderson, L.W,J. and Krathwohl, D.R. (2001). A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. New York, US: Addison Wesley Longman.
Darwazeh, A.N .(2017). A new revision of the [revised] Bloom's Taxonomy. Distance Learning, 14 (3), 13–28.
Durabi‘ah, I.T. (2006). Tahlīl 'Asyilat Al-Isti‘Yāb Fī Kitāb "Lughatunā Al-‘Arabiyyah" Lil-Ṣaff Al-Rābi‘ Al-Asāsī Fī Al-‘Urdun Fī Ḍaw’ Mustawayāt Bloom Al-Ma‘Rifiyyah ‘Analysis of Comprehension Questions in The Book “Our Arabic Language” for The Fourth Basic Grade in Jordan in Light of Bloom’s Cognitive Levels’. Master’s Thesis. Faculty of Graduate Studies, Amman Arab University, Jordan. [in Arabic]
Education and Training Evaluation Commission. (2019). Al-Iṭār Al-Takhaṣṣuṣī Li-Majāl Ta‘Allum Al-Taqniyah Al-Raqamiyyah ‘Specialized Framework for the Field of Digital Technology Learning’. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: King Fahd National Library. [in Arabic]
Fatlawi, F.A., and Abd, H.M. (2017). Taḥlīl muḥtawā kitāb al-ḥāsūb lil-ṣaff al-thānī al-mutawassiṭ wafq mahārāt al-tafkīr al-manṭiqī ‘Content analysis of the computer textbook for the second intermediate grade according to logical thinking skills’. Journal of Educational and Psychological Research, 14(53), 82–104. [in Arabic]
Gloga, R. and Sabina, K. (2013). Mastering cognitive development theory in computer science education. Computer Science Education, 23(1), 24–57.‏
Margana, D., Agustinsa, R., and Susanto, E. (2017). Cognitive Level Analysis of Problems in Mathematics Textbook Class XII Revision 2018 Materials of Congress and Construction Based on the Revised Bloom Taxonomy. Journal of Education and Learning Mathematics Research (JELMaR), 2(2), 14–25.
Ministry of Education. (2023a). Taqrīr Malāmiḥ Taṭwīr Al-Manāhij Al-Dirāsiyyah ‘Āmī 1443 Wa 1444 ‘Report on the Features of Curriculum Development for the Years 1443 and 1444’. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Ministry of Education. [in Arabic]
Ministry of Education. (2023b). Dalīl Al-Khuṭaṭ Al-Dirāsiyyah Al-Muṭawwarah: Niẓām Al-Fuṣūl Al-Thalāthah ‘Guide to the Developed Study Plans: The Three-semester System’. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Ministry of Education. [in Arabic]
Ulum, M. and Grmek, M. (2019) . The use of textbooks in the teaching-learning process. New Horizons in Subject-Specific Education: Research Aspects of Subject-Specific Didactics, n/a(n/a), n/a.
Yamani, A., and Sajini, M. (2018, September 30). Mā Hīya Al-Mahārāt Al-Ḍarūriyyah Limustaqbal Al-Ṭullāb? ‘What Are the Essential Skills for the Students’ Future?’. Makkah Newspaper, Makkah, Saudi Arabia. [in Arabic]