Imam Aldamadi’s Critiques (1638) of Imam Alsoyuti’s Work (1505): Analytical Study

(Hatem M. Mazroaa)

---

Abstract

This article analyses and criticises Imam Aldamadi’s critiques of Imam Alsoyuti’s thoughts. The preface introduces the imams and the terms mentioned in their works. This research used the analytical method in combination with examination and comparison. It was found that most of Imam Aldamadi’s critiques of Imam Alsoyuti’s thoughts dealt with linguistic issues, and that there is no specific term to express the integrity of Imam Aldamadi’s critiques. Three critiques seem fair, and three seem questionable. There should be further research examining Imam Aldamadi’s critiques of Alzamakhshari’s and Albaydawi’s writings.

KEYWORDS
Islamic following, Islamic selections, Islamic interpretations, Alzideia’s interpretations

PDF

References

Abu Hayyan, M.Y. (2001). Albahr Almoheet ‘The Surrounding Sea’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Aleilmiaa House. [in Arabic]
Abu Zahraa, M.A. (n/a). Zahrat Altafasir ‘Flower of Interpretations’. Cairo, Egypt: Alfeker Alarabi House. [in Arabic] 
Alakbari, A.A. (n/a). Al Tebyan Fi Ierab Al Quran ‘Explanation in the Parsing of The Quran’. Cairo, Egypt: Eisaa Albabii Alhalabi Publisher. [in Arabic]
Alalusi, M.A. (1998). Ruh Almaeani ‘Spirit of Meanings’.   Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Aleilmiaa House. [in Arabic]
Albaghawi, A.M. (2000). Maalim Altanzeel ‘Descending Features’. Beirut, Lebanon: Ehyaa Alturath Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Albaydawi, A.O. (1997). Anwar Altanzeel ‘Descending Lights’. Beirut, Lebanon: Ehyaa Alturath Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Aldamadi, A.A. (2018). Al Forat Alnameer fi Tafsir Alketab Almuneer ‘Alfurat Alnamir in The Interpretation of The Enlightening Book’. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Saudi Scientific Society for the Holy Quran and its Sciences (Tebyan). [in Arabic]
Alghozy, M.M. (1997). Alkawakeb AlSaaerah ‘Traveling Planets’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Alelmiaa House. [in Arabic]
Aljwhari, I.H. (1987). Alsehah ‘The Goodness’. Fourth edition. Beirut, Lebanon: Aleilm Lelmalayeen House. [in Arabic]
Almahali, M.A. and Alsoyuti, A.A. (n/a). Tafsir Aljalalyn ‘Interpretation of Aljalalyn’. Cairo, Egypt: Alhadeth House. [in Arabic]
Almaraghi, A.M. (1946). Tafsir Almaraghi ‘Interpretation of Maraghi’. Cairo, Egypt: Mustafaa Albabi Alhalabi Company. [in Arabic]
Alnasafi, A.A. (1998). Madarek Altanzeel Wa Haqaiq Altaaweel ‘Descending Perceptions and Facts of Interpretation’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkalem Altayeb House. [in Arabic]
Alqasemi, M.J. (n/a). Mahasen Altaaweel ‘The Advantages of Interpretation’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Alelmiaa House. [in Arabic] 
Alqazweni, A.F. (1979). Mujam Maqayees Alloghah ‘A Dictionary of  Language Standards’. Damascus, Syria: Alfekr House. [in Arabic]
Alqennawji, M.S. (1992). Fath Albayan ‘Statement Opening’. Beirut, Lebanon: Almaktabah Alasria. [in Arabic]
Alqurtubi, M.A. (1987). Aljamie Le Ahkam Alquran ‘Quran Rules Collector’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Alelmiaa House. [in Arabic]
Alrafee, M.S. (2005). Eejaz Alquran ‘Quaran Miracle’. Eighth edition. Beirut, Lebanon: Alketab Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Alrazi, M.O. (2000). Mafateeh Alghayb ‘Unseen Keys’. Third edition. Beirut, Lebanon: Ehyaa Alturath Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Alshaukani, M.A. (1992). Irshad Al Phuhool  ‘Guide The Stallions’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alfekr House. [in Arabic]
Alshaukani, M.A. (1993). Fath Alqadeer ‘Almighty Opening’.  Damascus, Syria: Ibn Katheer House. [in Arabic]
Alshaukani, M.A. (n/a). Albadr Altaalee ‘Full Moon Rising’. Beirut, Lebanon: Almaarefa House. [in Arabic]
Alsoyuti, A.A. (1974). Alitqan Fi Olum Alquran ‘Perfection in the Sciences of the Quran’. Cairo, Egypt: Egyptian General Book Authority. [in Arabic] 
Altabari, M.J. (2000). Jamie Albayan ‘Declaration Collector’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alresala Institution. [in Arabic]
Alzahabi, M.H. (n/a). Altafsir Walmufasirun ‘Interpretation and Commentators’. Six edition. Cairo, Egypt: Wahbaa Bookstore. [in Arabic]
Alzahrani, N.S. (2009). Istedrakat Alsalaf  Fi Altafsir Khelal Alqurun Althalatha Alolaa- Derasa Naqdiaa Muqarna ‘The Predecessor Corrections in Interpretation During The First Three Centuries - a Comparative Critical Study’. Alriyadh, Saudi Arabia: Ibn Aljuzi House. [in Arabic]
Alzarkashi, M.A. (1957). Alburhan Fi Olum Alquran ‘The Proof in The Sciences of  The Quran’. Cairo, Egypt: Ehyaa Alkutub Alarabia House. [in Arabic]
Alzerekli, M.M. (2002). Alaalam ‘Celebrities’. Fifteenth Edition. Beirut, Lebanon: Aleilm Lelmalayeen House. [in Arabic]
Deraz, M.A. (2005). Alnabaa Alazeem ‘Great News’. Damascus, Syria: Alqalam House. [in Arabic]
Haji Khalifa, M.A. (n/a). Kashf  Alzonoon ‘Uncover Suspicions’. Beirut, Lebanon: Ehyaa Alturath Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Ibn Aashur, M.M. (2000). Altahrir Waltanwir ‘Liberation and Enlightenment’. Beirut, Lebanon: Altarikh Alaarabi Institution. [in Arabic]
Ibn Alemad, A.A. (1986). Shatharat Aldahab ‘Gold Nuggets’. Damascus, Syria: Ibn Katheer House. [in Arabic]
Ibn Aljawzi, A.A. (2001). Zad Almaseer ‘The March Supplement’ Beirut, Lebanon: Alkitab Alarabi House. [in Arabic]
Ibn Atiaa, A.G. (2001). Almuharar Alwajiz ‘Brief Edition’. Beirut, Lebanon: Alkutub Aleilmiaa House. [in Arabic] 
Ibn Katheer, I.O. (1999). Tafsir Alquran Alazeem ‘Interpretation of the Great Quran’. Second Edition. Alriyadh, Saudi Arabia: Tayba House for Publishing and Distribution. [in Arabic]
Ibn Manzor, M.M. (1993). Lisan Alarab ‘Arabes Tong’. Third Edition. Beirut, Lebanon: Sader House. [in Arabic]
Mathkur, A.M. (2011). Istedrakat Ibn Aashour Ala Alrazi Wa Albaydawi Wa Abi Hayyan ‘The Correction of Ibn Aashour on Alrazi, Albaidawi and Abu Hayyan’. PhD Thesis, Umm Alqura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia. [in Arabic]
Rasheed Reda, M.R. (1990).Tafsir Alquran Alhakeem ‘Interpretation of The Wise Quran’. Cairo, Egypt: Egyptian General Book Authority. [in Arabic]
The Ministry of Awqaf and Islamic Affairs. (2007). Almawsuah Alfeqhiah Alkuaytiah ‘Kuwaiti Fiqh Encyclopedia’. Second Edition. Kuwait, Kuwait: Alsalasel House. [in Arabic]